Derivatives Limitations

Question

Why is it difficult to compute a perfect value of a derivative?

Accepted Answer

Computing the perfect value of a derivative, such as an option, is inherently difficult due to various complex and interrelated factors. Here are some of the primary reasons why this is challenging:

Model Assumptions and Limitations

 	Black-Scholes Model
One of the most widely used models for pricing options is the Black-Scholes model. However, this model relies on several assumptions that do not always hold true in real markets:

 	Constant Volatility: The model assumes that the volatility of the underlying asset is constant over the life of the option. In reality, volatility can change due to market conditions.
 	Log-Normal Distribution of Returns: The model assumes that asset returns are normally distributed, which may not be accurate, especially in markets prone to extreme events or "fat tails".


 	Alternative Models
Even more complex models, such as the Binomial Model or the Heston Model, introduce their own sets of assumptions and complexities, and they also cannot perfectly capture market behavior.

Market Factors and Conditions

 	Volatility
Volatility is a crucial input in pricing derivatives, but it is difficult to predict accurately. Historical volatility might not represent future volatility, and implied volatility can change rapidly based on market sentiment. The implied volatility is a 'forward looking' number, because you're pricing in a volatility value that you expect the underlying asset to endure during its time to maturity.
 	Interest Rates
Interest rates, which are another input in derivative pricing models, can fluctuate and are influenced by central bank policies, economic conditions, and market expectations.
 	Dividends
For derivatives on stocks, the timing and amount of dividends can impact the option's value. Predicting future dividends can be uncertain.

Liquidity and Market Microstructure

 	Bid-Ask Spread
The market prices used for calibrating models and computing derivatives values can be affected by the bid-ask spread, especially in less liquid markets.
 	Market Impact
Large trades can impact the market price of the underlying asset, which in turn affects the value of the derivative. This market impact is challenging to predict and incorporate into pricing models.

Behavioral Factors

 	Investor Behavior
Market prices are influenced by the behavior of investors, which can be irrational or driven by factors not captured by traditional models. Psychological factors, herd behavior, and sentiment can all impact the pricing of derivatives.
 	News and Events
Unexpected news, economic reports, political events, and other external factors can cause sudden changes in market conditions, making it difficult to predict derivative values accurately.

Title	Category	Subcategory	Difficulty	Status
Cash Settlement	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Easy	Unlock
Clearinghouse	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Medium	Unlock
Contango	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Hard	Unlock
Contract Size	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Easy	Unlock
Counterparty Risk	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Easy	Unlock
Credit Default Swap	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Easy	Example
Futures Roll-Over	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Medium	Unlock
Futures vs. Forward Contract	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Easy	Unlock
Leverage	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Easy	Unlock
Margin	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Medium	Unlock
Most Important Indices	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Easy	Unlock
OTC-Traded Derivatives	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Medium	Unlock
Swap	Derivatives Theory	Derivatives General	Easy	Unlock

The Interview Guide for Quants and Traders